Steel is one of the most commonly used materials in the world. Steel is used for an unlimited amount of different applications. From giant steel beams in skyscrapers to small machine screws. Steel is available in 1,000s of unique alloys– a few dozen are used for most applications. Each steel alloy has a specific combination of elements that give it unique properties.
Carbon steel and alloy steel describe two different groups of steel alloys. The key difference that separates carbon steel from alloy steel depends on what elements are—or are not—added to the recipe.
Understanding the differences between carbon steel and alloy steel will help you decide which material is best for your machined steel parts.
Every type of steel is a mixture of mostly iron, and other metallic and nonmetallic elements. The alloying elements largely influence the durability, corrosion resistance, cost, and machinability of the steel.
While both are iron-based, the specific elements added to the mix change the material’s strength and durability, price, and how easily we can machine it into your final part.
Carbon Steel is the reliable, cost-effective foundation of the steel world. Its properties are defined almost entirely by its carbon content.
Alloy Steel This is the "upgraded" category, where elements like chromium, nickel, and molybdenum are intentionally added to deliver specific performance boosts.
Carbon steel is the go-to material for a massive range of machined parts, and for good reason. As the foundational family of steel, its properties are almost entirely dictated by its carbon content. While other elements are present in small, residual amounts, the percentage of carbon defines how the material behaves.
This means you can select a specific type of carbon steel that matches your cost and performance targets.
We typically machine two main categories:
High-carbon steel, which has a carbon content between 0.6% and 1.0%, is known for being extremely hard, strong, and wear-resistant. Because of the challenges in machining it, high-carbon steel is less common for precision machined parts and is instead the material of choice for applications where extreme hardness is the primary goal. You typically find it used for high-tension springs, hand tools, and industrial blades
When standard carbon steel can't handle the pressure, heat, or stress of your application, you move to alloy steel. Think of it as steel that has been custom-formulated for a specific, demanding job. We start with the foundational iron-and-carbon recipe and then intentionally add other elements—the "alloys"—to achieve targeted performance enhancements.
These alloying ingredients are chosen to improve specific material properties. Common additions include:
4140 Steel: This is the all-around performer in the group. It offers an excellent combination of strength, toughness, and wear resistance, making it a top choice for a wide range of high-stress components.
4130 Steel: This grade has a lower carbon content, which gives it one key advantage: superior weldability. It’s often specified for components that need to be securely welded into a larger assembly without sacrificing significant strength.
41L40 Steel: The "L" in this grade stands for leaded. A small amount of lead is added to the steel, which improves its machinability. For high-volume production runs, using 41L40 can reduce cycle times and lower machining costs.
Alloy steels are an ideal choice for manufacturing high-stress components across several industries:
While alloy steels have a higher material cost, they provide the consistent quality and performance necessary for critical parts where failure is not an option. It's an investment in reliability for your most challenging projects.
Here are some common applications for both types of steel.
Spex is an ISO 9001:2015 certified company. Organizations use this standard to demonstrate the ability to consistently provide products and services that meet customer and regulatory requirements.
We incorporate world-class excellence in every step of the process, in our ongoing efforts to ensure your success.
Reach out to our team to get a quote for CNC machined steel parts for your next project.
